My New Favorite YA Contemporary?? || Book Review of "The Truth About Happily Ever After"

I've been reading YA books for years now, and I've read enough to know my tastes usually don't fall into the Romance/Contemporary niche. Sure, there have been a couple I enjoyed (see "To All The Boys I've Loved Before" and basically anything Morgan Matson) but it's truly not an area in which I find books I love. 
So needless to say, I was pretty shocked when I found myself adding a new contemporary romance to my "Favorites" shelf on Goodreads. 

This book is "The Truth About Happily Ever After" by Karole Cozzo, author of two other YA books, "How to Say I Love You Out Loud" and "How to Keep Rolling After a Fall".



Here's a quick synopsis: Alyssa is a 20 year-old college student who works as Cinderella at Enchanted Dominion during the summer. She lives, breathes, and loves all things Enchanted, especially her job that lets her dress up and bring magic into the lives of the kids and families who visit the theme park. 
It's the summer before her junior year of college and Alyssa is primed and ready to have the most wonderful summer of her life. A big part of this excitement stems from the fact that her boyfriend, Jake, will be working at Enchanted Dominion alongside Alyssa (they meet there last summer- how cute!) But things don't go as princess-perfect as Alyssa hoped, and plans begin to crumble, and Alyssa begins to rethink what "happily ever after" might really mean for her.

So first of all, this book is basically Disney World YA. If you like Walt Disney World and all the parks and excitement and magic that comes with it, then this book will charm you! I don't always like when authors try and take something so major that exists IRL (like Disney) and turn it into their own version (Enchanted Dominion), but Cozzo does this masterfully! Nothing feels cheapened or un-Disney; Cozzo creates a wonderfully vivid park that feels real and original instead of ripped off. #BrowniePoints

Here are some of the best things about "The Truth about Happily Ever After"!

*Really great female friendships & defying stereotypes

Alyssa is surrounded by some really lovely girls in her life: there are her fellow park princesses (aka the Princess Posse) who look out for one another and are super sweet. Can I get an "amen!" for women writing women who actually build each other up instead of compete constantly?! All the love to Cozzo for that. Then there are Alyssa's sorority sisters who come to visit- their chapters were hilarious to read! I adore Cozzo's narrative on Greek life and how she wrote the ZTA sisters in a slightly cliche but realistic way- it was very Elle Woods and very well done! Cozzo wrote some very silly, fun-loving college girls who care deeply for their sisters and have found a little family in each other. At one point, Alyssa reflects on why she loves ZTA so much and says she works hard for her place there because she loves having a life that feels solid and where she feels like she belongs. She doesn't mind working insanely hard to deserve her place in the sorority, especially after having an unstable family living condition.
Speaking of hard work...

*Girls working hard at careers & taking care of themselves!

Alyssa is uber passionate about her job at the park. She takes care to maintain her Cinderella appearance and takes pride in what she does. Working at Enchanted Dominion isn't just a clock-in-clock-out job for her; no, she believes in the magic of the parks and is willing to do anything to add to that magic for others. She knows little girls look up to her so she commits herself to certain standards.

"Playing princess isn't nearly as easy as I'm sure some people like to believe. It's a dream job, but it's still a job. There's work involved." -Alyssa, page 4

There is also a wonderful narrative in this book about being proud of yourself and your body, and it's very positive. Alyssa takes care of her body with healthy food and exercise to keep herself in shape for her job. And when things in her life start to go wrong and she stops eating from stress, she's got a friend there who outright asks her if she needs help with an eating disorder.
There's a very good balance of self-care and "treat yo self" attitudes in this book. Alyssa has a good mind for how her body works and she is happy with who she is.

"It's not superficial, wanting to look my best and be a part of a group and feel good about myself. It doesn't feel that way to me, not after having so much fall apart around me when I couldn't do anything to control it." -Alyssa, page 141

*Accurate portrayal of relationships

Relationships don't always work out like they do in an Enchanted Enterprise film; the original OTP prince and princess may realize they don't work out as a couple. Alyssa and Jake's relationship isn't quite what it was the summer before, and when Alyssa begins to realize this, it breaks her a bit. She really tries to piece things back together. But your first love isn't always going to be your Prince Charming.
I think the relationships in this book were very realistic. There were problems, arguments, misunderstandings, and heart-to-heart convos that I think many YA readers will be able to learn from. And not just the romantic ones either, but the friend-to-friend talks Alyssa has are very honest. 

*Things that weren't Happily Every After
*A handful of fragmented sentences/awkward phrasing
I feel like this is an editing issue more than anything. There were a handful of spots where sentences could have been restructured to avoid fragments.

*Lack of closure with Alyssa hiding her money situation from the sorority
I thought this was going to be a slightly bigger issue since Alyssa brought it up several times. The last we heard from the sorority end of things was that Alyssa was still going to share a room with two other girls to save money (#relatable) but she was hiding the money aspect of that from everyone. I think a little more closure on that end would have been nice, whether it was from Alyssa telling her sisters about it or something else.


All in all, this was a marvelous YA read full of magical moments and characters with tons of heart! I was so enchanted while reading this I thought a fairy godmother had put a spell on me!  I would absolutely recommend this book, especially as a fun spring/summer read.
5/5 exceptional stars!

Here's a link to buy: "The Truth about Happily Ever After" 




Diversity Bingo 2017: March Update

Woohoo! Three months in 2017 and I'm feeling quite good about my current progress on #DB17! After reading only 2 books towards this challenge in February, I made a point of focusing in on diverse books this month. And I read some really good ones, too! It really is a nice feeling when you can read challenge books and fall in love with them as well. :)
In the interest of avoiding making this post super long, I'm not going to give a plot summary for each, but rather just a short little blurb of my thoughts- enjoy!

Square: Main Character w/ an Invisible Disability
Book: "Under Rose-Tainted Skies" by Louise Gornall
Rating: 5/5
I had never before read a book where the main character has agoraphobia, so this was a very informative read for me. It was very clear and honest about how Norah's agoraphobia, OCD, and anxiety are part of her every day, and readers get a clear look at how she lives.
My favorite part about this novel was that the romance/love interest was not portrayed as a "cure" for Norah. Meeting a cute boy wasn't what helped her begin to overcome her mental illness. Ultimatley, Norah helps Norah. She creates her own path forwards. She is a brave young woman, but that doesn't mean she's not scared or broken sometimes. A top notch read!

Square: POC on the Cover
Book: "Lies We Tell Ourselves" by Robin Talley
Rating: 2.75/5
While this was a wholly interesting premise, set in a crucial point in American history, "Lies We Tell Ourselves" just didn't work for me. First, I think this would have been an entirely more effective novel had it been shorter. There were a lot of moments of inner dialogue where a character would just ask themselves questions over and over- a lot of  repetitive inner exposition. I felt like the romance in here, while interesting, was a little forced. It felt too instalove for me, and I truly didn't see how the main characters clicked with each other. While both mentioned how invigorating it was to have someone else to argue with and discuss things with, there just seemed to be a lack of real drive behind the relationship. 

Square: Neurodiverse MC
Book: "Queens of Geek" by Jen Wilde
Rating: 3.25/5
First of all, this was fun! I really have a soft spot for books that involve comic/pop culture conventions. Three friends from Austraila, A YouTube sensation and her two BFFs, attend SupaCon in California. Shenanigans, costume contests, super stars, anxiety, and romance ensue. In my opinion, the best part of "Queens" was its frank and open narrative on mental illness, anxiety, OCD, and sexuality. These were discussed in a natural and understanding way, and I think any young teen reading can find a friendly, relatable voice in Charlie or Taylor.
My biggest dislike about this one was that the writing felt very juvenile.It lacked lyricism and any sort of complex literary construction, and it felt like the characters were spelling out every situation verbally simply for the readers sake. There are also a lot of  heart-to-heart moments that were a bit too cheesy. And the ending, while happy, felt like I was watching a teen flick where all the main characters come together and toast their future and throw their arms around each other *cue Ben Rector's "Brand New" song for credits*. So yeah, I think this is a great book for younger teens, but Wilde could definitely step up her writing style.

Square: MC of Color in SFF
Book: "Afterworlds" by Scott Westerfeld
Rating: 5/5
I'll admit it: I've actually had this book sitting on my shelves for about two years now because, while I really like Westerfeld's writing, I had seen a couple reviews that talked about the supernatural part of this novel and it kinda turned me off. I'm just not a fan of death god/grim reaper/urban fantasy themes and I thought that was all this was.
I was WRONG.
Yeah, death is a big theme in this one, but that's not all it is. Westerfeld masterfully ties together a book within a book, creating a story about publishing, the YA community, love, the afterlife, ghosts, and death all into one great epic story that transcends the definition of "supernatural" reads. It's difficult to pin this book down in such a short review, but I will say that between the two layers of stories in "Afterworlds", I could not put this down! I would finish a Darcy chapter, and then immediately be pulled back into a Lizzie chapter. It was an addictive read!

Square: d/Deaf/Hard of Hearing MC
Book: "You're Welcome, Universe" by Whitney Gardner
Rating: 5/5
Like "Under Rose-Tainted Skies", Gardner's novel features a main character unlike any I've previously read. Julia is a Deaf teen who loves and is fascinated by graffiti. She is a refreshingly relatable character: she deals with homework, has passions she pursues, deals with friend troubles, and actually works a part time job (I don't understand how so many YA characters just...don't work? Ever? Movie studios don't count).
Anyway, I was constantly learning so much from this! Julia would mention something about Deaf culture or how she moves about in the world or some tidbit of street art rules, and I'd have a moment of, "Dude, I never thought about that." Just reading about how she deals with ignorant teachers speaking louder to her, or moments when she mentions a graffiti technique- it was all so interesting. "You're Welcome, Universe" was a very eye-opening read, and I desperately want more books about Julia!

Square: Immigrant/Refugee MC
Book: "The Sun Is Also a Star" by Nicola Yoon
Rating: 4/5
Wow! This novel definitely was not what I was expecting. Usually, I don't really enjoy books that are told within the time period of a day, or even a couple days. I find them lacking in plot and development. Yoon, however, does a marvelous job of weaving the past, present, and intangible all together to tell the story of two young teenagers on the brink of change. My favorite aspect of this novel were the threads of lives Yoon wove together using background characters and concepts (such as Natasha's hair!) to create a more robust picture.
I felt a little cheated by the ending- those moments when years suddenly are flying by and readers only get a bunch of catch-up scenes where Yoon just tells us everything that's been happening. It felt a bit rushed to me. Additionally, Natasha's father was a key figure in this book, but despite all the discussion of him, his motivations still elude me. I feel like he could have been more fleshed out or written with better motivations.

The Unpopular Opinions Book Tag || (Or, "I Really Don't Love Romance Books")

This is a book tag that was created by TheBookArcher on YouTube, and it's one of my favorite tags to see others do! I love seeing everyone's unpopular opinions, and thought it was past time I offered mine up. Of course, as everyone says, these are my personal opinions- you can love the books I don't, and vice versa. :) Anyway, here we go! 

Question #1: A popular book or series that you did not like

"Looking For Alaska" by John Green. I mean...I just don't get the hype. So many people love this book, and that's totally fine. But "Looking for Alaska" fell flat. I thought the "twist" was anticlimactic, the characters were unlikable, and it just didn't click for me. 

Question #2: A popular book or series that everyone else seems to hate but you love

This is a book series I started reading well before I started book blogging or watching booktube videos, and when I did I was shocked to see how many people said they disliked it. I'm talking about the "Crossed" trilogy by Ally Condie. The primary reason I see people say they don't like it is because of the second book, "Crossed". I'll admit, it's definitely not the strongest second book. But the trilogy as a whole I really enjoyed! 

Question #3: A love triangle where the main character ended up with the person you did not want them to end up with OR and OTP you did not like

This actually isn't a very heated question for me! Honestly, I usually like whatever the author has written, or grow to like the relationship as I read further. For the answer though, I think I'm going to
go with Four and Tris from "Divergent". Mainly because I thought they were each way too emotional and dramatic to be in a relationship in the first place, and also because their voices sounded so alike- I disliked reading dialogue between them because they sounded like verbal twins! 

Question #4: A popular genre you hardly reach for

Romance! I've totally tried reading a few romance books, and there were a couple I like, but as a whole romance is just not a genre that calls to me. I like romance in books (hello, Nina and Matthias) but I can't think of a single full-on romance novel that I love. "To All The Boys I've Loved Before" by Jenny Han is probably the closest! Although I think technically that's classified as "contemporary YA"? 

Question #5: A popular or beloved character you did not like

Freaking SEVERUS SNAPE!! This dude is awful! And yes, lots of characters in the Harry Potter series do some messed up stuff, but I really don't get how people defend Snape and call him "strong" and "misunderstood". He was horrible to young children, unforgiving, abusive, and vile. As a character he is interesting but it blows my mind when people say they love him. 

Question #6: A popular author you can't seem to get into

This definitely ties back into the popular genre I can't get into, but Sarah Dessen. I mean, I've read a couple of her books and thought they were fine, but again: romance just isn't my thing. Her writing style is good, and she's created some very engaging characters. It's just those romantic plots that turn me off of her books. 

Question #7: A popular book trope you're tired of seeing

Oops, sorry, another answer that revolves around romance! I'm definitely tired of seeing forbidden love romances. Whether it's because a parent forbids it, or there's an "incest" theme (looking @ you, Shadowhunters), or the two characters are from different worlds/realms/races, forbidden romances just don't excite me! 

Question #8: A popular series you have no interest in reading

I don't know if it's because I see this series at work all the time, or if I'm worried it will mess up my love for the original "Wizard of Oz" film, but I really don't see myself reading the "Dorothy Must Die" series anytime soon. Retellings are always a hit-or-miss for me, too. If someone thinks I'll really love this then I might read it, but it will take a lot of convincing. 

Question #9:The saying goes, "The book is always better than the movie" but what movie or TV show adaptation did you like better than the book? 

I'm sorry for this, Patrick Ness, but the "A Monster Calls" movie was simply gorgeous unfolding on
the silver screen. Your book was, too! However, the scenes where the monster was telling stories to Connor were simply captivating. The inky watercolors and fluid movements made me feel as if I were the one being spoken to. I think seeing the emotions unfold on screen were incredibly well done! *

Introduction to Graphic Novels || 5 Tips for Where to Start Reading

Before I started reading graphic novels, I was always a little intimidated by them- the sheer size of the selection at most stores was enough to make me skip reading them! It wasn't really until 2015 that I slowly began picking them up. "iZombie" had just premiered on TV, and I was curious to read the graphic novels that inspired the show. Then I just slowly started picking up different ones from the library, and reading ones I saw recommended from YouTube videos.

What I'm saying is that delving into the realm of graphic novels can be a little daunting. Superheroes, zombies, girl gangs, dystopian tales and more all vie for attention in splashy colors and glossy pages.
I thought I would offer up some advice on how to pick out where to start. So here are 5 tips, plus a few reading suggestions, for those who are new to graphic novels! Enjoy! :)

#1) Check out Goodreads lists

It's like browsing at the bookstore expect without the stress of seeing stuffed shelves overflowing with choices!  You can see a plot summary, reviews, and if a particular novel is part of a series or a single book. Plus, there are dozens of themed list on GR that can help you narrow in on a particular topic or theme.
HERE is a list with graphic novels that have badass women characters. HERE's one about graphic novels that are focused on (mostly) real historical events. And HERE is a list of supernatural (but not superhero) reads.

#2) Think about genre- what genres do you already like? Fantasy? Nonfiction? Contemporary? If you like a certain kind of book, say horror, then staring with similar graphic novels may be a good way to start. It's familiar grounds! You can use Tip #1 and look for lists of a certain genre, or ask a librarian or bookstore worker for a recommendation.

*Suggestion for a horror graphic novel: Try "Wytches" by Scott Snyder- very eerie and unsettling! If you like Stephen King or Josh Mallerman, I would recommend this!



#3) Start with standalone reads
Instead of picking up the first in a long-running series, try reading a single complete graphic novel. There are hundreds of Batman graphic novels, so even if you're a batfan (pun intended), finding your starting place there will be a little trickier than just a single read. There's no commitment to a series, just the enjoyment of one beautiful book.

*Suggestion for a standalone: "This One Summer" by Mariko & Jillian Tamaki- a contemporary coming-of-age story that has a very nostalgic and wistful feel.
Illustration from "This One Summer". Art & credit to
Jillian Tamaki
#4) Real life stories
Some of the best graphic novels I've read have been memoirs or semi-biographical reads. There is no fantasy world you have to get acquainted with, or any zombies to worry about- nonfiction is refreshingly predictable sometimes! If you like biographies then I would highly recommend starting here.

*Suggestion for nonfiction graphic novel: "Fun Home" by Alison Bechdel- a highly acclaimed biographical work that that centers on sexuality, family, and womanhood.

#5) Go younger: yes, the Kids section!
I browse the Kids section of bookstores and libraries just as much as I do the "adult" section. And for a good reason, too! Kids/middle grade books are deceivingly simple- don't let the colorful covers and
smiling characters fool you. Graphic novels aimed at kids almost always have themes that are universally relatable: finding yourself, making friends, loss of a loved one, and the love of adventure.

*Suggestion for Kids graphic novels: "Amulet" series by Kazu Kibuishi if you want a world of monsters and family themes, or maybe "Anya's Ghost" for a standalone about a girl who befriends a spirit-but not all is as it seems. 


There you go! I hope some of these tips helped you think about where to start reading graphic novels, or even a new novel to pick up.
Thanks for reading!

If You Liked This Book, Read This Next || #1

Have you ever finished a book or series and wished the author had written more? It's one of the most frustrating things a bookworm can experience when they realize a beloved book is over. Book hangovers are a real thing, people.
I've seen a couple videos where bloggers recommend books that are similar to other titles, and I thought I'd do the same! It's a really phenomenal way to discover books that are close enough to what you like to enjoy it, but of course, each book is different so there's a whole new story to be found.
So, here are four book-to-book recommendations I hope you'll enjoy!


If You Liked: 
"History Is All You Left Me" by Adam Silvera
Read:
"We Are Okay" by Nina LaCour

Similar Themes Include: Grieving; death of a loved one; loss; depression; LGBT+ main characters.

Both of these novels are multilayered stories that each move backwards and forwards in time, weaving a narrative of death and the impact death has on the ones left behind. Yes, both of these are pretty heavy and have quite a few teary moments. But they're also hopeful and lyrical in their own right.

If you liked:
"Everything, Everything" by Nicola Yoon
Read:
"Under Rose-Tainted Skies" by Louise Gornall

Similar Themes Include: Main characters who cannot leave their houses; potential boy-next-door romances; dreams of traveling; close relationships with mothers.

Quite honestly, it's remarkable how two books can be so similar and yet also so different. Both deal with teenage love, illness, and acceptance. There is a great mental health narrative in "Under Rose-Tainted Skies" as it talks about OCD, self harm, and anxiety. "Everything, Everything" has a bit more of a classic contemporary feel to it. And while I won't spoil the ending I will say that both books have some pretty eye-popping twists that I did not see coming!


If you liked:
"An Ember in the Ashes" by Sabaa Tahir
Read:
"The Valiant" by Lesley Livingston

Similar Themes Include: Setting in Rome/Roman-inspired world; fighting and battles; threads of magic; strong female warriors; controlling empires; captured main characters; schools for battle training.

I just mentioned these two books together in my review of "The Valiant", but they're worth mentioning again! These are modern day epics, stories of bravery and heroics, of flaws and fighting. Maybe I have "a type" but I truly love books with ancient Rome vibes and badass warriors. They're never a dull read! Plus, there are really swoon-worthy soldiers in both. ;) If you want a daring, nail-biting read, these are the books for you. Just know they're a little bit graphic, what with all the sword fighting and whatnot.

If you liked:
"Fangirl" by Rainbow Rowell
Read:
"A Little Something Different" by Sandy Hall

Similar Themes Include: college setting; creative writing/English classes; "cute & fluffy" contemporary reads; characters placed together via class project; shy main characters.

Looking to get a little more of that slightly geeky, adorable "Fangirl" vibe? Sounds like you need "A Little Something Different" (lololol). Ahem. Truly though, both of these are fun and grin-inducing books that will make you want to start writing fanfiction or stories of your own. There are cute college boys, opportunity-filled class projects, and charming moments that will make you go "awww!" Rowell's book brings the fanfiction, and Hall's brings a whopping 14 different viewpoints to her story (even a squirrel??).


I hope you found some new books to check out from this list! I'll be making a Part #2 later in March, so stay tuned! :)

Top 5 Wednesday: Books You Felt Betrayed By

Et tu, Brute? 

March 15 is the Ides of March, so today's Top 5 Wednesday topic asks us to talk about the books or characters that betrayed us the most. 
To try and avoid major spoilers, I'm going to keep my answers relatively short. However, BE WARNED: Number 2 contains a big spoiler for "Mockingjay" by Suzanne Collins, so skip that one if you haven't read it. There was really just no way for me to explain my answer without outright stating what happened. 

1) "The Heart Goes Last" by Margaret Atwood

I was really excited about reading this when it first came out: a blogger I like had raved about this, and it had been several years since I had read anything by Atwood. I actually received an advance copy of this and dove right in...but was quickly shocked at how much I had to force myself to keep reading. This had been marketed as an adult dystopian novel with elements of romance and survival. But honestly? This book is about: Sex. Robots. Unfaithful spouses. More sex. Jail. 
"The Heart Goes Last" feels very jumbled and forced, like it's trying to be "Edgy" and "Jarring" but it simply spiraled out of control to me. It really turned me off of picking up anything by Atwood anytime soon. 


2) "Mockingjay" by Suzanne Collins

Let me clarify- it wasn't this whole book I felt betrayed by, but rather a very specific moment. So
basically right after Katniss shoots Coin instead of Snow like she is supposed to, she passes out. And a lot of stuff happens after she passes out but we as readers don't get to see all that action!! Conveniently, Katniss wakes up after everything has been dealt with and gets an easy-peasy summary of what occurred. 
So really, the betrayal is really from Collins! I think having a character pass out during a pivotal moment it just laaaaazy writing. I enjoyed "Mockingjay" as a whole, but this scene (or rather, lack of) just always gets under my skin.

3) Edmund Pevensie in "The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe"

I mean, come on! What Narnia-loving child didn't feel a little angry at Edmund after he sold out his siblings for a bunch of Turkish Delight? First of all, Turkish Delight is the nastiest kind of candy and Edmund clearly had no taste. Second (and I'm repeating myself here) he sold out his siblings for candy. Really, Edmund was a first rate noob! I'm glad Edmund got some great character development later (he's actually one of my favorite characters now) but man, rereading the first Narnia story always irks me a little bit because of Edmund's selfishness. 

4) Jesper Fahey in "Six of Crows" by Leigh Bardugo


So I'm not going to go into detail on this one because of, again, spoilers, but there is a moment in "Six of Crows" when something about our favorite sharpshooter is revealed and I audibly gasped when
reading it. Bardugo wove such a busy and elegant story with so many layers that I truly did not see this moment coming, but in hindsight, it totally made sense! *applause to Bardugo* Jesper is by far one of the most complicated characters in this duology, and I loved seeing him shift about in his various roles. 
Ah, my little criminal children never fail to disappoint me. :) 




5) "Harry Potter and the Cursed Child" by JK Rowling, Jack Thorne, and John Tiffany

Confession time: this book came out summer of 2016, and it is now March
2017 and I've yet to finish this book. I keep trying, but just can't get past the first few scenes. And it's not the play format; I actually rather like plays and dramas. It's the writing. Storyline. All of it. I've seen reviews where people write about "Cursed Child" seeming like just fanfiction, and so far, I agree with that. Sure, I'll read the whole thing at some point...someday...not soon. I've really tried to read this three different times but there's an obvious lack of Rowling in it. I'm not feeling the magic with this. 





So there you go! Hope you enjoyed reading this week's T5W- if you'd like more info on the group and upcoming topics, check out the Goodreads group here
Until next Wednesday! 

"The Valiant" by Lesley Livingston || Book Review



Photo by Deborah Embury
When I about 14, I began reading historical fiction. That's not a very exciting sentence, but in the context of my reading life, it meant a big change had just happened. Up until then, fantasy was the genre that pulled me into most books and made me stay up late reading. But historical fiction quickly began pulling me into its pages. One of the historical fiction novels that sparked my interest in reading more broadly was "Cleopatra's Daughter" by Michelle Moran. It was a sprawling story of a book, set in ancient Rome and Egypt, and it was full of adventure, far off places, and settings which simply captivated me.

Since then, I have loved reading books that are set in or inspired by ancient Rome (see "An Ember in the Ashes" by Sabaa Tahir) and am always looking out for new releases in that vein. At the end of 2016, I began to hear chatter in the YA community about an upcoming book called "The Valiant" by Lesley Livingston- and I knew I needed it. I requested it from my local library, but after reading the first few chapters, I placed an order for it, too. I was hooked.
Having now read "The Valiant" I am so ready to go buy more of Lesley Livingston's books, because this one was stupendous.

PLOT
"The Valiant" is a young adult novel that follows the story of Fallon, the daughter of a Celtic warrior
king, part of a ferocious tribe in Durovernum. Fallon wants to follow in the footsteps of her deceased sister, Sorcha, a brave and fearless warrior who died on the battlefield. But things take a turn when Fallon's father announces she it not to become a warrior, but rather be wed to a prince from another tribe. When she decides to take matters into her own hands, Fallon finds herself captured by slavers from Rome. She is taken far from her homeland and bought by an elite training school for female gladiators. And this school? It happens to be owned by the man Fallon despises most- Julius Caesar.

FALLON
Right from the beginning of the story, readers see how determined Fallon is. She attempts chariot tricks no one else dares, she speaks her mind, and she is a strong fighter who wants to be even better.
After the wedding announcement is made, we see this strength as she decides her fate:

"I would be the master of my own fate. Me and the goddess Morrigan. No one else- and certainly no man. Mael and Aeddan could fight over me until they were both bloody. My father could deny me my blade. But they couldn't force me from my warrior's path unless I let them."

Fallon refuses to let anyone tell her she cannot be who she wants to be. At first, I was a little worried that Fallon might be one of those heroines who is essentially a "Mary Jane"- no flaws (EVER), always right, and always putting other people in their place. But that's not true. As Fallon's story progresses, she finds herself in situations where her beliefs are challenged, and what follows is some beautiful character development.
Photo by Deborah Embury

Fallon doesn't want to fight in a school owned by Caesar. Her tribe has fought against him for years, and Fallon despises the thought of fighting for him. But other characters encourage Fallon to think about what she can accomplish by doing so.

"You think I should fight for Caesar?"
"I think you should fight for yourself," he said. "But those things needn't be exclusive. Temper passion with control, conviction with cunning."

"Temper passion with control" is a perfect way to describe Fallon's character arc. She is fiery, brave, and smart, but also a little stubborn. Throughout the book, she learns to use her attributes to fight for what she wants, even in bad situations.

"Be an idealist, by all means, but be a pragmatic one."

SISTERHOOD & FEMALE FRIENDSHIP
The friendship between Fallon and Elka, a fellow gladiatrix, was  by far one of the best parts of "The Valiant". What started as two captive girls at odds with one another quickly became two strong girl fighting side by side to survive. Elka is also a captive, and she and Fallon don't start out on the best terms. Both stubborn and spirited, they literally butt heads before ending their friendship truly begins.

I actually got quite emotional reading about Fallon and Elka. As much as I love reading Young Adult novels, one of the aspects I think is not very well represented is female friendship. Livingston does a marvelous job here, writing two young women whose friendship develops and grows in a genuine way.
Fallon and Elka fight for each other. They train together, each encouraging one another. They joke, they confide, and they look out for one another. After their initial fight, there is no moment when Livingston uses their true friendship as a plot device to make drama.
Yes, there is another female character, Nyx, who acts as a foil to Fallon. But even in the end, Fallon tries to do what she thinks is right and save Nyx from a horrible fate (see bottom of page 370). Fallon recognizes that she has the chance to give something better to someone who hates her, even if it may be a little difficult for Nyx to adjust.

The theme of female empowerment is strong in "The Valiant". The school in which Fallon learns is a sisterhood, where are the girls are expected to bind together and find freedom among themselves, even if it's not in the "normal" sense of the word freedom. During an oath ceremony, Livingston writes:

"This oath is the oath we all swear. Not to a god, or a master, or to the Ludu Achillea...but to our sisters who stand here with us. Our sisters. This is the oath that binds us all, one to one, all to all, so that we are no longer free. We belong to each other. We are bound to each other. In swearing to each other, we free ourselves from the outside world, from the world of men, from those who would seek to bind us to Fate and that which would make us slaves. We sacrifice our liberty so that, ultimately, we can be truly free."

At the start of the novel, Fallon believes being free to run about the forests of her home is true freedom. She doesn't understand how freedom can be found anywhere else. But throughout the book, she encounters characters who have made a life for themselves and are completely happy- even though they are slaves. One such character says to Fallon, "I've made my own freedom, and that is something I'll never give up."
Later, another female character confronts Fallon about her belief of what freedom is and what it can be. She asks Fallon is fighting over cattle back home was more honorable than what was going on in Rome. She proclaims that she is fighting for Fallon and for a sisterhood.
Photo by Deborah Embury

ROMANCE
At one point, I was really upset because I thought this was about to become a love triangle romance- but it didn't! The romance in "The Valiant" is lovely because it takes a back burner to the main story arc.
I don't want to say too much about the romance and spoil it for anyone, but I will say I very much enjoyed how Livingston brought two worlds together in the romance. She allowed both her characters and readers to learn something from the clashing of worlds, and we were allowed a look at both of the characters motivations and thoughts.
(also, the love interest is <3 <3 <3 )

OTHER
My only issue I had reading this was that, geographically, I was confused a bit at the beginning of the book. Livington uses older names of countries/cities, so I had to go and Google a couple names to find out where they were. For instance, Fallon is from Dunvernum, which I found out is actually modern day Canterbury in England. Clearly I knew where Rome was, but during the beginning of the book I needed to figure out where we were starting. I think a map would have been a good addition to the book (maybe we'll see one in the second?). It wasn't a huge factor at all, I just think it would have been helpful for the first half of the book.

CONCLUSION
If you are a fan of "An Ember in the Ashes" read this book.
If you like historical settings woven with a hint of magic, read this book.
If you like strong female characters who fight and grow, read this book.

This was a wonderful, epic read that transported me to ancient Rome in a heartbeat. It is woven with hearty descriptions, sharp dialogue, and a cast of characters that felt incredibly lifelike. I will absolutely be adding more books by Lesley Livingston to my bookshelf!
5/5 stars!!